The pension success paradox: when a bigger pot creates a new protection need

Catherine Trimble

Head of intermediary distribution for protection

Sometimes a financial plan creates a new problem because it’s worked so well. 

Take a client who’s saved steadily throughout their working life. They reach retirement with a healthy pension, draw only what they need and leave the rest invested. When they die, there’s still a significant amount left. 

Nothing has gone wrong. Quite the opposite. 

But from April 2027, that unused pension wealth could affect the inheritance tax position of the estate. A plan that gave the client security throughout retirement may leave their family facing a tax bill without an obvious source of cash. 

That’s the pension success paradox. The pension has done exactly what it was meant to do, but the protection planning around it may no longer fit. 

Retirement outcomes vary widely. Scottish Widows’ latest Retirement Report estimates that 31% of UK adults risk being unable to cover their basic needs in retirement.1 At the other end of the spectrum are clients who may die with substantial wealth still held across pensions, property and investments. For them, the question isn’t only whether they’ve saved enough. It’s whether the wider plan still works when that wealth passes on. 

From 6 April 2027, most unused pension funds and pension death benefits will be brought within the value of a deceased person’s estate for inheritance tax purposes. It won’t affect every client, but for some it could change the inheritance tax position of an estate that also includes property, savings and investments.2 3 

HMRC expects most estates with inherited pension wealth to remain outside inheritance tax. Even so, it estimates that around 38,500 estates could pay more tax than under the previous rules, with the average increase expected to be around £34,000.4 

They’re forecasts, not individual outcomes. But they raise a very practical question. If a tax bill did arise, where would the money come from? 
 

A valuable estate doesn’t always mean there’s cash available 

A client can leave behind a valuable estate without leaving their family with money they can easily access. 

The home may not be intended for sale. Investments may be providing an income for a partner or set aside for future generations. The pension may have been viewed as the last asset the family would ever need to touch. 

Then the tax position changes. 

Would the family need to sell something? Could investments have to be accessed at the wrong time? Might beneficiaries need to use their own savings or borrow while dealing with everything else that follows a death? 

These questions can reveal a protection gap that may not have existed when the original pension plan was put in place. By the time the family discovers the shortfall, the client is no longer there to change the plan. 

Life cover won’t remove the inheritance tax liability. But where the problem is a shortage of accessible cash, it can provide the money the family needs without forcing them to sell or rearrange other assets. Looking at the gap earlier gives the client and their family more choice. 
 

Could the pension review uncover a life cover need? 

As April 2027 gets closer, a pension review could be a natural moment to ask: 

How much might still be left in the pension when the client dies? 

Could that change the inheritance tax position of the estate? 

If a bill arose, what accessible money would be there for the family to meet it? 

Is there already life cover in place, and would it still be enough? 

The answers won’t always point towards more protection. Spending, gifting, investment choices or estate planning could all form part of the picture. 

But where the gap is simply a lack of accessible cash, life cover is worth discussing. 

Existing cover deserves another look too, without assuming the answer is more cover. A client may already have a policy, but the amount, term or purpose could have been set years ago, before the pension and estate grew. Having cover isn’t quite the same as having the right cover for the job it may now need to do. 

A review doesn’t need to uncover a gap to be worthwhile. In some cases, the existing cover will still fit. In others, the need may have grown or changed. 

Ownership matters as well. The way a policy is arranged and how its proceeds reach the intended people could make a real difference, alongside legal and tax advice where appropriate. 
 

When pension success changes the protection need 

The 2027 change isn’t only a reason to explain new pension rules. It could open protection conversations with clients who haven’t previously appeared to need more cover. 

Not every successful saver will face an inheritance tax bill, and life cover won’t be the answer in every case. But some clients could leave behind plenty of wealth and still leave their family short of cash at exactly the wrong moment. 

The pension review may uncover a need that wasn’t there when the original plan was written. Not because the pension has fallen short, but because it hasn’t. 

The pension may have done its job, but it could still be worth checking whether the protection around it is ready to do its job too.  
 



Sources:

1 Scottish Widows 2026 Retirement Report 

2 Finance Act 2026 

3 HM Revenue & Customs, Technical note: Inheritance Tax on pensions, updated 29 May 2026.  

4 HM Revenue & Customs, Inheritance Tax on unused pension funds and death benefits, published 21 July 2025, and the subsequent consultation response.